Lindsay Clancy scored a legal win on Thursday in her bid to stop her second murder trial.
Clancy’s defense team will now go before the full Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, after a justice ruled Thursday that her double jeopardy challenge deserves a review and oral argument. A three page order stamped Nov. 19 determined that Clancy’s petition will be considered by the full court.
https://twitter.com/conlin_lauren/status/2123434752397005262?a=FWdDkNKYI9UvNPHVVrg&s=20
The good news for Clancy hits just three days after her attorneys filed a Nov. 16 petition pushing back against Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan’s refusal to dismiss the murder charges.
Clancy, who has pleaded not guilty, is accused of killing her three young children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, inside their Duxbury home in January 2023. Her first trial ended Sept. 4 after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict, resulting in a chaotic mistrial.
In her order, Justice Elizabeth Dewar acknowledged that “extraordinary relief is reserved for exceptional circumstances,” but concluded that a review by the full Supreme Judicial Court was warranted.
The decision doesn’t mean Clancy has won her appeal or that the charges have been dismissed. It means the state’s highest court will consider whether she can legally face another trial- and the bar is high.
The argument goes back to the handling of a holdout juror during Clancy’s first trial. As Los Angeles Magazine recently reported, newly obtained transcripts of previously private sidebar discussions show disagreements between Sullivan and defense attorney Kevin Reddington over how to respond to notes from the jury foreperson. The foreperson alleged that one juror was refusing to follow the court’s instructions on reasonable doubt, though her second note only used the word, “doubt.”
Credit: Commonwealth of Massachusetts SCJSullivan questioned the jurors individually, and each juror confirmed they could follow his instructions. But Clancy’s defense argued that Sullivan should have investigated the foreperson’s concerns more in depth before declaring a mistrial.
In their Nov. 16 petition, attorneys Marty Weinberg, Michael Pabian and Reddington argued that Sullivan failed to exhaust alternatives to a mistrial, meaning a second trial would a violate Clancy’s constitutional protection against double jeopardy.
The prosecution has also pushed back against Clancy’s attempt to stop the retrial, filing a 46-page opposition on Nov. 18. Prosecutors content that Judge Sullivan was justified in declaring a mistrial after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.
Dewar has ordered both sides to agree on the main facts of the case and submit their arguments to the court under a tight deadline. Clancy’s attorneys have until Dec. 3 to file their arguments, while prosecutors have until Dec. 17 to respond. The defense can then submit a final response by Dec. 28.
Both sides are expected to appear before the court in January 2027 to argue their positions. Dewar also made clear that neither side should expect extra time to file its paperwork.
Clancy’s retrial remains scheduled for March 29, 2027, with another Plymouth Superior Court hearing set for Dec. 30 and a pretrial conference scheduled for Feb. 18.
The post Lindsay Clancy Scores Court Victory in Fight to Stop Second Murder Trial appeared first on LAmag.