Highland Park Methodist Court Order Takes Effect After Church Posts $5,000 Bond

Posted
Highland Park Methodist Court Order Takes Effect After Church Posts $5,000 Bond
Highland Park Methodist Name Order Takes Effect After $5,000 Bond _ Image by Canva

A Dallas County judge’s temporary restraining order limiting a United Methodist regional conference’s use of the historic Highland Park church name has taken effect after the Dallas congregation posted a required $5,000 bond on Thursday, November 19, court records show.

Judge Bridgett Whitmore of the 193rd District Court granted Highland Park Methodist Church’s request in part on November 18. Her order bars the Horizon Texas Annual Conference from using “Highland Park United Methodist Church,” “Highland Park United Methodists,” “Highland Park UMC,” “HPUMC,” “HPUMC Oasis,” and confusingly similar names.

The order also restricts soliciting or accepting donations under the disputed names, suggesting affiliation with Highland Park Methodist Church, and displaying disputed branding online. It directs the parties to preserve potentially relevant records.

The Dallas County district court docket for case DC-26-14816 identifies a $5,000 TRO cash bond as “POSTED” and lists a bond filing on November 19. The posting satisfies the order’s bond requirement. The ruling expressly allows the conference’s congregation to continue worshiping under a different, noninfringing name.

Church Leaders Welcome The Ruling

In a November 19 email to members, a copy of which reached The Dallas Express, Highland Park Methodist Church leaders welcomed the ruling.

“We are grateful to share that the Court has granted Highland Park Methodist Church’s request for a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO), protecting our church’s longstanding name and identity.”

Church Council Chair Caroline Nowlin and Pastoral Relations Committee Chair Mark Freeman signed the message, which said the congregation respects the other group’s right to worship but objects to names that could confuse the community.

“We wish our neighbors well and respect their right to worship and build a faith community under a name that does not infringe on our historic trademarks or create confusion within our community.”

The leaders said the church remains hopeful that the Horizon Texas Conference will choose a path that allows both congregations to move forward.

How The Dallas Dispute Escalated

The Horizon Texas Conference sued the church in August over revisions its Church Council made to governing documents beginning in 2022. The conference maintains that those changes bypassed required United Methodist approval, altered the corporate name, and transferred governance and pastoral authority to local leaders.

Highland Park leaders dispute that account and maintain that they acted within the congregation’s lawful authority. Of 4,775 votes cast October 25-26, 90.35% favored ending ties with the denomination, as The Dallas Express previously covered. The conference maintains that a local vote alone cannot sever the church’s denominational relationship.

Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. subsequently appointed the Rev. Andy Lewis to lead members who wanted to remain United Methodist. That group began holding services at Southern Methodist University’s Prothro Great Hall on November 15, near the original congregation’s longtime sanctuary at 3300 Mockingbird Lane.

Other Congregation Responds

Lewis described the ruling as disappointing in a November 18 message to congregants, which United Methodist News quoted on November 19.

“This news is disappointing, but I want you to hear from me that I remain undeterred in our mission to offer a United Methodist ministry and witness to the Highland Park community and beyond,” Lewis wrote.

Lewis said his congregation would regroup and temporarily take down its website. The conference has also maintained that the underlying lawsuit concerns denominational governance and the legal effect of church documents and a property deed, not simply the public-facing church name.

National Religious Leader Comments On Separation

Evangelist Franklin Graham, president of Samaritan’s Purse and the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, praised the congregation’s decision to leave the United Methodist Church in a November 16 post on X. Graham attributed the departure partly to disagreement over the denomination’s acceptance of LGBTQ clergy and same-sex marriage, calling its direction an “unbiblical progressive movement.”

Graham also praised former President George W. Bush and former first lady Laura Bush for supporting the congregation’s vote. “Thank you Highland Park Methodist Church and President Bush for doing the right thing and standing with the Word of God,” Graham wrote in his post.

Highland Park Methodist Church has emphasized governance and congregational autonomy in explaining the separation, rather than framing its decision as a dispute about sexuality. Graham’s comments preceded the November 18 ruling and did not address the restraining order.

In a statement following the ruling, the Horizon Texas Conference said it remained committed to Lewis’ congregation and its ministry. “We remain confident in our position and believe the courts will ultimately bring clarity to these matters,” the conference said in a statement published by United Methodist News.

What Happens Next

The November 18 order does not decide the validity of the church’s 2022 governance changes, the congregations’ ultimate denominational status, or property ownership. The court denied the conference’s jurisdictional plea at this preliminary stage but has not reached a final judgment on those questions.

The restraining order expires at 4 p.m. December 2 unless the court extends it or the parties agree otherwise. Whitmore set a temporary injunction hearing for 10:30 a.m. that day via Zoom. The case docket also lists a December 7 hearing at 11:15 a.m. on a motion to dismiss and an October 12, 2027, non-jury trial. The litigation remains open.

Provided by Dallas Express

Dallas Express