
The 67-acre Diamond District site is bordered by Arthur Ashe Boulevard, Hermitage Road, the interstate and the railroad tracks. (BizSense file)
Legal clouds surrounding the Diamond District continue to get thinner, as a previously lingering court battle between current and former developers on the project has been officially resolved, according to a recent court filing.
Attorneys for Thalhimer Realty Partners and its former teammates on the project, Republic Properties and Loop Capital, notified the court last week that they had resolved the remaining claims in what had once been a $40 million lawsuit that Republic brought against Thalhimer and Loop two years ago.
The notice to Circuit Court Judge Bradley Cavedo states that “all matters in dispute between them have been fully resolved” via an agreement, the terms of which were not disclosed. The filing requests that the case be dismissed with prejudice, meaning it cannot be brought again in the court.
The confidential settlement resolves two claims that remained in the case: breach of contract and unjust enrichment, both of which related to nearly $864,000 in expenses that Republic said it was owed from Thalhimer and Loop. Cavedo last year threw out eight other counts that alleged fraud, conspiracy and other claims that made up the rest of the $40 million in damages sought.
Reached Monday, Thalhimer attorney Hal Johnson, with Richmond firm Williams Mullen, declined to comment on the settlement. Attorneys for Republic and Loop did not respond to requests for comment.
Republic, which is based in D.C. and part of Connecticut-based Republic Holdings Corp., enlisted Thalhimer and Loop in a previous iteration of the Diamond District development group. The group won the project in 2022 through an RFP process, but Republic later withdrew from participating in the public-private development after refusing to sign off on final terms with the city.
Thalhimer later formed a new project entity and entered into a revised development agreement with the city. The local firm is now leading the project solo, as Loop, based in Chicago, also bowed out of the project and asked to be dropped from the suit.
Republic maintained that Thalhimer and Loop breached a business venture when they continued with the development without Republic, arguing that the venture was formed through the parties’ pursuit and award of the project. Thalhimer and Loop maintained that the parties never came to terms on or signed a venture operating agreement.
Thalhimer countersued Republic last year, soon after a separate lawsuit was filed against Republic by Capital Results, a local PR firm that said it was owed over $200,000 in fees for work performed as part of the Republic-led development team.
It isn’t clear whether the settlement also resolves the Capital Results case, which remained listed as active in circuit court as of Monday. Ed Tolchin, an Offit Kurman attorney representing Republic in both cases, did not return a call seeking comment.
Capital Results is represented by Eric Feiler and Michael Brady with Whiteford, Taylor & Preston. A call to Feiler was unreturned Monday. Dan Herbst with Reed Smith represented Loop Capital in its case.
The Nov. 11 notice requesting the Republic-Thalhimer-Loop lawsuit’s dismissal was submitted a year to the day of the last filing in the case, which had remained in a sort of pre-trial-discovery limbo since Cavedo’s ruling that struck the other eight counts.
It also followed the recent settlement of another lawsuit involving the Diamond District and Thalhimer – the federal defamation case between Richmond Flying Squirrels owner Lou DiBella and Jason Guillot, the Thalhimer principal now leading the Diamond District.
A separate lawsuit from the Squirrels’ ownership group, Navigators Baseball, against the city and the Richmond Economic Development Authority remains active in Richmond Circuit Court.
In that suit, DiBella and the Navigators claim fraud, alleging that the group was induced to invest tens of millions of dollars above their original commitments to develop CarMax Park, which anchors the Diamond District, based on representations the city and EDA made about the project and their selected developer, both of which the Navigators claim have changed substantially from when the city awarded the project.
That suit, which also names Thalhimer and development group Diamond District Partners as defendants, was filed and served on the parties in early September. (Previous BizSense reports that said those services involved subpoenas were incorrect.) No filings have been entered in the case since responses to the suit were filed later that month.
The post Confidential settlement wraps up 2-year-old lawsuit between prior Diamond District teammates appeared first on Richmond BizSense.